The photograph above is titled From the Archive. This photograph was taken by Wing Young Huie
between the years of 1997-2000 in Lake Street, USA. This black and white photo
shows five men standing in a line in which four of these men are Caucasian, the
fifth being Asian. These men are standing at a crosswalk in front of Gap in
what seems to be a big shopping area. Looking deeper into this picture, we
realize that the Asian man and is mimicking the posture and gestures of the
fourth, Caucasian, man by putting his hands on his hips. This shows how white
men are considered higher than others and how the “others” want to be in
control or be considered to have just as much power as a white man. In The Handmaid’s Tale, by Margaret
Atwood, “othering” is presented in a similar way as displayed in the picture.
Atwood displays Offred as a character that struggles to fit in with society
since women are valued much less than men, just like Asians are compared to
whites. Some readers might relate to
Offred by feeling like a stranger to their community, while others could feel
detached from her because of their dedication to the fit in with the
culture displayed in their surrounding environment.

This is a great choice as far as image- while the subjects are all men, they all share similarities beyond gender and differences as far as appearance. I think you border on generalizations or assumptions here- try to first just state what is in the image or text, and then look more at choices made. To say the Asian man is mimicking the others' poses is a generalization, but to say the photographer composed the image so it appears as if he is is no longer an assumption.
ReplyDeleteIs Offred struggling to fit it? Or does she accept her role and fate without accepting the society?